The Falls Church Healthcare Center is due for several coats of paint. Located about 30 minutes outside Washington, D.C. in Falls Church, Virginia, it’s a nondescript mid-century office building in a standard commercial strip. There’s a waiting room that’s decorated with a mini-stone fountain and displays of paper flowers.
The inside of the clinic could do with some fresh paint too, but that’s not high on anyone’s priority list, admits Dr. Sara Imershein, M.D., who performs first-trimester abortions at the clinic once a week and one Saturday per month. It doesn’t need to look like a spa – it needs to get one critical job done.
‘We do everything we can to keep the costs down for the patients,’ Imershein tells me. She used to have a private OB-GYN practice near posh Dupont Circle, but after 30 years, she shut her doors. Rather than spend her retirement playing tennis or travelling to Europe, Imershein is using her time to perform abortions – exclusively. When Imershein sent out an email at the end of 2015 to let colleagues and patients know her plans, a college friend responded, ‘You’ve been working toward this ever since you were in college.’
When Imershein meets with patients at Falls Church, she begins by washing her hands and introducing herself by name. She checks the patients’ charts one last time and answers any remaining questions they may have. ‘Sometimes they’ll ask, “Will it hurt?”‘ Imershein says.
By that time, all patients have already undergone an ‘extensive’ counselling session including open-ended questions designed to make sure they’ve chosen the procedure on their own. In Virginia, Imershein’s patients have also already undergone a legally-required ultrasound and waited at least 24 hours before being allowed to see her.
‘Just to make it clear, the first waiting period for most women is from when the pee stick changes colour to when she picks up the phone and makes an appointment. Her second waiting period is from when she makes the appointment until when she shows up here,’ Imershein says, noticeably frustrated by the fact that a woman’s third waiting period is mandated by law. (There is no waiting period or ultrasound prerequisite for patients just across the border at Planned Parenthood of Metropolitan Washington, D.C., where Imershein also works.)
Most ambivalent patients are screened out by clinic staff, but occasionally, they make it to Imershein. In one case, a woman told Imershein that another doctor had said she needed an abortion because she had been on the pill and her child would likely have complications as a result. When Imershein told her the risk of abnormality was incredibly low, their conversation quickly turned to prenatal care.
Being pro-choice means providing women with whatever health care they need, not just abortions: ‘I feel good when I help women make the decisions they want, and live the lives they want,’ Imershein says. Giving women access to whichever option is best for them not only fulfills Imershein’s role a doctor, she clarifies, but as a Jewish woman too. The two roles are intertwined.
While cleaning out her office last December, Imershein found a single typed page she had written for herself before giving a speech to a Jewish group at the Washington Hospital Center in the mid-1990s. The note was tucked away in a file on methotrexate, a drug that can be used to end a pregnancy within the first seven weeks. The first sentence reads, ‘Abortion is not murder,’ and includes a paraphrased version of Exodus 21:22. According to the verse, if two men are fighting and one man accidentally hurts the other man’s pregnant wife, and her fetus is lost, he must only pay a fine. The loss of a fetus is not treated like the loss of a human life.
In the tradition of Reform Judaism, abortion is not only tolerated but may even be commanded if the life of the woman is in danger, or if she is in physical or psychological pain, Imershein tells me. ‘A woman who is carrying an abnormal fetus, however, can’t make the decision based on the suffering of the child, but on her suffering,’ she adds. ‘I like that. I like the idea that a woman should have to make a decision herself, and that she shouldn’t be compelled for any reason except her own.’ Imershein describes herself as coming from a ‘long line of liberal Jews.’ Over Sabbath dinners with her family, she was taught the principles of tzedakah and tikkun olam – ‘justice’ and ‘repairing the world.’ Imershein’s desire to help people is rooted in her faith, but her advocacy is driven by a firm belief that abortion should only be seen as a medical issue. ‘Women’s health is medical, not political,’ she insists. Even though abortion is legal in the United States, decades of lobbying by anti-choice activists have made it inaccessible in certain parts of the country. By enacting burdensome provisions that mandate counselling, extensive waiting periods, and ultrasounds, conservative lawmakers have made it harder for low-income patients and patients in rural areas to access the care they need. In 25 states, more than half of women live in a county without a clinic that provides abortion, according to the Guttmacher Institute.
There are risks that come with being an outspoken abortion provider in the United States, and Imershein has had her share of frightening run-ins with pro-life advocates. In the summer of 1995, an unknown group distributed flyers in the neighborhoods of OB-GYNs throughout the D.C. area, calling out physicians by name.
‘The flyer said that I was a “murderer worse than the KAPOs in the concentration camps” – so worse than the Jews that were overseers of other Jews during WWII,’ she says. A similar flyer, covered in feces, appeared on Birnkrant’s door. ‘I was scared,’ Imershein says. ‘Doctors were being murdered.’ In the spring of 1993, Dr. David Gunn was shot to death by an anti-abortion protestor outside of his clinic in Pensacola, Florida. Dr. George Tiller of Wichita, Kansas, whose clinic had been firebombed in the 1980s, was shot in both arms later that year. He was later killed by an anti-abortion activist during a church service in 2009. Most recently, in 2015, a man who declared himself a ‘warrior for babies’ killed three people in a shooting at a Planned Parenthood clinic in Colorado Springs, Colorado.
Fortunately, the office building housing the Falls Church clinic is surrounded by private parking space, meaning picketers must stay on the sidewalk and can’t stand outside the door. But their numbers have increased since the 2016 presidential election. ‘Some of the protesters yell, but we just ignore them,’ says Imershein, who no longer fears for her safety inside the ‘buffer zone’ of the beltway.
Parker, an OB-GYN and devout Christian, provides abortions to women in the Southern states with the most restrictive abortion laws. Though he admits he once believed abortions were morally wrong, he eventually came to see providing abortion care to women in need as his ‘life’s work’ (the title of his newly released memoir). Imershein appreciated his directness: ‘He didn’t do abortions, then he realised there were women in need. Very matter of fact.’ ‘Maybe I just have my head in the sand,’ she says. ‘But I am so morally committed to providing this care and using my medical skills in a way that is so empowering, and wow, I get told “Thank you” every day on top of it. How cool is that? When I start being more afraid for myself than the women who need me, I am giving in to the antis.’ Imershein doesn’t care what anti-abortion advocates believe, but she despises the use of religious freedom as an argument for impeding access to abortion. She calls it ‘religious intrusion.’ ‘Religious freedom is the freedom to be left alone, not the freedom to create laws based on one group’s religion,’ she argues. ‘I don’t think if you cut off your own arm you will be jailed, or if you attempt suicide you will be jailed. But if you try to self-abort, you can be put in jail in some states.’ In fact, 38 states allow a person to be charged with homicide if they’re deemed responsible for the unlawful death of a foetus, and many of those laws allow the formerly pregnant woman herself to be charged. At least a half a dozen women in the United States have been arrested and charged after attempting to self-induce an abortion with illegally obtained abortifacients, including a Virginia woman arrested in late March on felony charges of ‘producing abortion or miscarriage.’ These intrusions on women’s health have increased since Donald Trump took office, according to Imershein. In his first week, the new president reinstated the ‘global gag rule,’ a Reagan-era ban on federal funding for international health organisations that perform abortions. And in March, Vice President Pence cast a tie-breaking vote in the Senate to give states permission to withhold federal funds from Planned Parenthood facilities.
‘I wake up every morning angry and frustrated at what is happening and what I see as the writing on the wall for women’s health, women’s rights, women’s ability to control their bodies,’ Imershein says. She strongly believes in the importance of training the next generation of OB-GYNs and believes that ‘every OB-GYN should learn how to do an abortion,’ not least of all because every professional organisation related to the field says knowing how to perform them is a basic skill requirement. ‘You wouldn’t become a cardiac by-pass surgeon and then limit your practice if you were religiously or morally against blood transfusions,’ she explains.
In the last academic year, she taught a class in reproductive health at GWU’s public health school. She tells me about one of her students, who said at the beginning of the course, ‘I think abortion is wrong and I’m trying to keep an open mind. Maybe you can convince me it’s not.’
‘I don’t want to convince you it’s right or wrong, that’s your values, your religion, your upbringing,’ Imershein replied. ‘What I want to show you is that the scientific evidence says that keeping it safe, legal, and available is good for public health.’
Via Marie Claire USA